Social Security at 70: FDR Did TOO Support Private Annuities; Kudlow Opines
Social Security celebrated its 70th birthday last week.
It also marked 70 years that the Social Security system has failed to carry out one of its godfather’s wishes:
Washington, D.C. - On January 17, 1935, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt explained that, “in the important field of security for old people, it seems necessary to adopt … voluntary contribution annuities by which individual initiative can increase the annual amounts received in old age.â€
Larry Kudlow notes where the system should be, actually must be, steered:
Unless Social Security is reformed substantially, by providing for the ownership of personal savings accounts that will permit stock and bond investments to finance benefits rather than tax hikes, the system will continue to deteriorate.
Only through market wealth creation will pension benefits for older Americans be fully financed over the long-term. If the government does not embrace this solution, it will break both hearts and promises as it raises taxes and cuts benefits time and again in the future — just as it has in the past.
Simply, the Social Security system will never be fixed until Congress realizes that President Bush is right: The ownership of market asset wealth — which is also a huge policy incentive to maintain our capitalist, free-market, economic-prosperity-creating machine — is the only solution. Sooner or later Washington will come to this realization.
I part with Kudlow on his certainty as to whether Washington will come around on individual investment accounts. I am hopeful, but recognize the fierceness of the opposition. Those who oppose individual accounts know that if they run out the clock for something like 5-10 years, it will become very difficult financially to pull off the transition. It’s sad but true: These people would rather have the elderly depend on the ability and willingness of future generations finance part or all of their retirement than give them full control over their financial destiny.









