November 25, 2005

Voting With Our Feet, Part 1: What Thanksgiving Is Partially About

Filed under: Economy,Taxes & Government — Tom @ 4:24 pm

The phrase that is the title of this post has been on my mind for a few weeks. Over the next several days, I’ll be citing examples of “vote with feet” situations and the impact they have had or will have.

Let’s start with the Thanksgiving holiday we celebrated yesterday.

Some of the Pilgrims of the Mayflower actually “voted with their feet” twice: first migrating to Holland to escape religious persecution in England, and then to America (after returning to England for others who wished to make the trip), not only to escape English pressure which had even continued from a distance, but also to establish a new community and begin new lives.

One of the thing we take for granted in the USA is our ability to move around, not only over vast distances, but from job to job, school to school, and neighborhood to neighborhood. The influence of our ability to do these things and from time to time carry them out is underappreciated, and has results many of those who don’t fully respect our mobility don’t appreciate.

Thanksgiving, among of course many other things, is a celebration of our ability in a free country to go elsewhere if need be to change our lives or achieve our dreams. Subsequent posts will explore the impact of our unprecedented ability to move around on many different areas of life.


Other “vote with our feet” posts:
- Part 2: It’s the Taxes, Stupid
- Part 3: Walking Away from Academic Excellence
- Part 4: Leaving Cincinnati (and Other Ohio Cities)
- Part 5: Willisms Looks at State Migration Patterns
- Part 6: Losing the Very Rich

An Interesting Take on What Thanksgiving Really Celebrates

Filed under: Economy,Positivity,Taxes & Government — Tom @ 12:01 pm

Though I believe the author misstates the role of religion in what we celebrated yesterday, and is a bit over-the-top on American exceptionalism (therefore I did not excerpt those segments), he is definitely on to something when he makes the following points about this unique American holiday:

Thanksgiving celebrates man’s ability to produce. The cornucopia filled with exotic flowers and delicious fruits, the savory turkey with aromatic trimmings, the mouth-watering pies, the colorful decorations — it’s all a testament to the creation of wealth.

Thanksgiving is a uniquely American holiday ….. It is America that has been the beacon for anyone wanting to escape from poverty and misery. It is America that generated the unprecedented flood of goods that washed away centuries of privation. It is America, by establishing the precondition of production — political freedom — that was able to unleash the dynamic, productive energy of its citizens.

This should be a source of pride to every self-supporting individual. It is what Thanksgiving is designed to commemorate. But there are those, motivated by hatred for human comfort and happiness, who want to make Thanksgiving into a day of national guilt. We should be ashamed, they say, for consuming a disproportionate share of the world’s food supply. Our affluence, they say, constitutes a depletion of the “planet’s resources.” The building of dams, the use of fossil fuels, the driving of sports utility vehicles — they insist — are cause, not for celebration, but for atonement. What if, they all wail, the rest of the world consumed the way Americans do?

If only that were to happen — we would have an Atlantis. For it would mean that the production of wealth would have multiplied. Man can consume only what he first produces. All production is an act of creation. It is the creation of wealth where nothing before existed — nothing useful to man. America transformed a once-desolate wilderness into farms, supermarkets and air-conditioned houses, not by taking those goods away from some have-nots, nor by “consuming” the “world’s resources” — but by reshaping valueless elements of nature into a form beneficial to human beings.

Since human survival is not automatic, man’s life depends on successful production. From food and clothing to science and art, every act of production requires thought. And the greater the creation, the greater is the required thinking.

This virtue of productiveness is what Thanksgiving is supposed to recognize.

….. The liberal tells us that the food on our Thanksgiving plate is the result of mindless, meaningless labor. The conservative tells us that it is the result of supernatural grace. Neither believes that it represents an individual’s achievement.

But wealth is not generated by sheer muscle; India, for example, has far more manual laborers than does the United States.

….. Wealth is the result of individual thought and effort. And each individual is morally entitled to keep, and enjoy, the consequences of such thought and effort. He should not feel guilty for his own success, or for the failures of others.

There is a spiritual need fed by the elaborate meal, fine china and crystal, and the presence of cherished guests. It is the self-esteem that a productive person feels at the realization that his thinking and energy have made consumption possible.

Postivity: Boy taken from mother’s arms found safe in California

Filed under: Positivity — Tom @ 7:10 am

An Amber Alert story–also note in the last paragraph the impressive results with the program in one state (HT Good News Blog):