Another “Alleged” Fraud in the Literary Community: JT Leroy
James Frey (third item at this post) was exposed by The Smoking Gun.
Unbeknownst to me, just before Frey’s Lies became common currency, “HIV-infected man” and hard-luck storyteller JT Leroy was almost definitively identified as a woman:
It has been one of the most bizarre literary mysteries in recent memory: Who, exactly, is the novelist JT Leroy? An answer, at long last, is taking shape.
Mr. Leroy’s tale was harrowing in its details and uplifting in its arc. He was a young truck-stop prostitute who had escaped rural West Virginia for the dismal life of a homeless San Francisco drug addict. Rescued as a young teenager by a couple named Laura Albert and Geoffrey Knoop and treated by a psychologist, he was able to turn his terrible youth into a thriving career as a writer. JT Leroy has published three critically acclaimed works of fiction noted for their stark portrayal of child prostitution and drug use.
Along the way Mr. Leroy gained the friendship and trust of celebrities and noted writers, who supported his career financially and offered him emotional support when he declared that he was infected with H.I.V. Sales were good, and his books were published around the world. Shy and reclusive, Mr. Leroy, now 25, appeared in public often disguised beneath a wig and sunglasses.
But the young man in the wig and sunglasses, it turns out, is not a man at all. The public role of JT Leroy is played by Savannah Knoop, Geoffrey Knoop’s half sister, who is in her mid-20’s.
A photograph of Ms. Knoop at a 2003 opening for a clothing store in San Francisco was discovered online. Five intimates of Mr. Leroy’s, including his literary agent, his business manager and the producer of a forthcoming movie based on one of his books, were shown the photograph and identified Ms. Knoop as the person they have known as JT Leroy.
….. But the discovery of the public face of JT Leroy is only part of the mystery. Still unsettled is the question of who writes under that name.
….. The unmasking of Ms. Knoop adds to a mounting circumstantial case that Laura Albert is the person who writes as JT Leroy. Pressure to admit the ruse has been building on Ms. Albert since October, when New York magazine published an article that advanced a theory that she was the author of JT Leroy’s books.
….. Ms. Albert did not respond to numerous voice mail messages requesting comment. Reached by telephone, Mr. Knoop declined to comment.
Ouch.
_____________________________
UPDATE: Blogosphere reax (some doubling up on James Frey) –
- Miz Almond: “In the aftermath of “Fake Writer Day,†I have to say I’m at a loss ….. I personally don’t believe that a body (Leroy) can learn to write that well and not figure out how to remove double negatives from their sentences when requesting review copies. ….. Dude (Frey) knows how to sell books, that’s for sure. But when you play in the cult of personality, your word(s) cease to be enough. It’s a dark and lonely crossroads, Big Jim.”
- Not Keeping Score (just read the whole thing)
- PhillyWriters.net: “So, it seems from all these juicy revelations that the wilder and more implausible your author bio is, the more attractive you are to potential publishers.”
- It’s My Dog’s World: “But just like our metabolisms, used to starve and binge in the wild, perhaps this is one adapative behavior (lying) that no longer works as well in our current info-overloaded environment, and this era, to quote Stephen Colbert, of Truthiness.”
- Conblogeration: “….. editing is different from inventing”
- American Caesar Salad: “I don’t think we have a satisfactory organ in society to shame people like this. What’s worse, they’ve already made trillions of dollars off of us - so it seems the jackasses win.”
- Sfist: ” The creative team behind J.T. Leroy should send James Frey flowers, since his little revelations have given the J. T. Leroy hoax story a sort of also-ran quality.”
- Tiny Mammoth: “I can’t think of any such fakery in the past, am I missing someone? There’s so little real suffering in modern life that the perfectly normal human act of enduring it has become exotic.”
- Under the News: “In America today, we live with too much fiction posing as fact. It’s not art to swear you’re telling the truth and then fib. That’s just common lying.”
- Loins: “January 9 Shall Forever Be Known as Fake Writer Day”
- The Quintonian: “Ah, it has been a good week for fraudulence about crapulence.”
UPDATE 2: The betrayed-by-Leroy Susie Bright weighs in at HuffPost (HT Michael Canfield).
UPDATE 3: Duped (but at least not dumped) Cherry Blossom Special — “I want to make note that I am ashamed to have ever been duped by this hoax, that the numerous secretive moves and inconsistent public appearances of JT Leroy should have tipped me off.”









