NOTE: This was originally posted at 1AM, but was moved to the top for most of the business day Thursday because of the importance of the topic.
_________________________________
All county endorsement processes in Ohio’s US Senate race, at least the open and fair ones, ended Tuesday night with the Fulton County shocker, where incumbent Senator Mike DeWine was defeated by his two challengers, both of whom earned a “qualified” designation.
So NOW, one of those challengers, David Smith, releases this “fact sheet” at his web site. I believe its content was posted sometime in the Tuesday-Wednesday overnight period (anyone with info to the contrary, please e-mail me).
How convenient. After forcing us to rely on this vague, platitude-laden bio for four months, NOW David Smith tells the world that:
- He’s lived in Ohio for no more than 19 months (not that you couldn’t find it, but from real estate records I’d rather not link to, the last purchase date listed at their residential address is August 24, 2005; however, since he ran in the June 2005 Second District Primary, you would think he had to have moved here sometime between August 2004 and March 2005).
- He ran for Congress in Utah in 2002.
- He ran for Congress in Tennessee in the GOP Primary on August 5, 2004.
- He ran for Congress in Ohio in the Second District GOP Primary that took place on June 14, 2005.
I think you’ll see shortly why Mr. Smith waited until now to let everyone know about those previous races.
Mr. Smith-Has-No-Chance-of-Going-to-Washington went to the Utah State GOP convention as a congressional candidate in May of 2002. The convention used what is known as Instant Runoff Voting:
In 2001, the Utah Republican Party adopted instant runoff voting (IRV) for elections that take place at its state conventions. Several counties also use IRV at their county conventions. The party uses IRV to elect officers and to nominate candidates — candidates can win outright at the convention or, if neither of the final two candidates has 60% support, advance to a runoff primary.
IRV was used to nominate congressional candidates in 2002.
Utah’s 2nd District began its IRV with twelve candidates. On each ballot, the last place finisher was eliminated. David Smith was ousted after the third ballot (the entire process of 11 ballots it took to get to the two primary opponents Bridgewater and Swallow is not shown for space reasons):

Apparently buoyed by the stunning success of getting sixteen (count ‘em) people to vote for him, Smith achieved the following result in August 2004’s First District Primary in Tennessee (available in a PDF that can be found at this link; click on “County Totals” under “U.S. House Republican Primary”):

And here is how he did, with the results of all other candidates listed, in the 2005 Second District Primary in Ohio:

Going from a bit over 10% of the vote in 2004 to less than 1% in 2005 is not something one would ordinarily define as “progress.”
Now let’s ask a few serious questions:
- Did David Smith disclose his complete residency history and electoral record to the endorsers listed at his web site before obtaining their endorsements?
- Would Smith have obtained their endorsements if he had disclosed them?
- How many members of county endorsement committees who voted for Smith, especially in Miami County (where he received 118 votes, or roughly 27% of the total) and Fulton County (where he garnered somewhere between 10-18 votes out of 28, and received a rating of “qualified”) would have voted differently if they had known his full residency history and electoral record? (I have one answer already from one of the two counties I just mentioned, which I will keep anonymous for the time being: “I DO think it would have made a difference.”)
More is coming, or as they say, “developing …..”