Top 10 Media Economic Myths of 2006
The Business & Media Institute has a list – Here it is (Go to their site for the Institute’s reasoning; my comments follow each item; HT Pundit Review).
10. American Manufacturing Is Obsolete.
In addition to the overemphasis on the misfortunes of the Big 3, the fact that the manufacturing sector expanded in every month from January through October, before contracting very slightly in November, never got out of the business pages (print or web). The 41 consecutive months of expansion in manufacturing that just ended is the longest streak since the 1970s.
9. The American Dream Has Become a Nightmare.
There are a lot of arguments here, but the best one is that real incomes have gone up in the past 10 and 20 years, contrary to what Paul Krugman told Neil Cavuto earlier this month.
8. You Can’t Be Trusted with a Fork and Spoon.
So, for example, trans fats have to be banned, because you’re too dumb to stop consuming them. Never mind, as the Wall Street Journal reported, that the science on the hazards of trans fats is dubious, and that some of the same consumer nannies who liked them 20 years ago are railing against them now.
7. Wages are stagnant.
This mostly covered in Number 9, but I’ll borrow from the BM&I a bit here for more support:
Hourly compensation in non-farm businesses increased 7.7 percent from last year, according to a September 6 report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
….. Compensation includes benefits, which have been a huge growth area. Workers are paying a lower share of their health benefits than they did in the past – something journalists didn’t factor into the overall earnings picture.
6. Global Warming Doom Grows Ever Nearer.
Where do you begin? Oh, just read this post on a “contrarian” story about carbon dioxide levels that the New York Times decided to published it on Election Day in November, perhaps so no one would notice it.
5. Increasing the minimum wage will help the millions of poor workers.
A little BM&I borrowing here will do the trick:
In fact, the percentage of hourly paid workers at or below the minimum wage is at its lowest point since data were first collected in 1979. In 1980, 15.1 percent of those workers were minimum wage or below – compared to 2.5 percent in 2005. More than 20 states already mandate wages higher than the federal minimum.
Several economists have pointed out that the majority of workers move on from entry-level minimum wage positions relatively quickly. The BLS reported that “about half of workers earning $5.15 or less were under age 25, and about one-fourth of workers earning at or below the minimum wage were age 16-19.”
So the “obvious” answer is to take the bottom rung or two off of the ladder so young people can’t get their working careers started. Zheesh.
4. The housing bubble has burst.
See the post “More Fun and Tom and Rex,” where yours truly responds to an exaggerated set of claims by MarketWatch reporter Rex Nutting. It’s not too late for disaster to strike, but so far, the housing story is “Bubble, Schmubble.”
3. Bird flu is going to kill us all.
Since I’ve done nothing with this (mostly non-) topic, I’ll let BM&I take this one:
Out of the world population of 6.5 billion, 258 people have caught the virus and 154 have died, according to the World Health Organization as of Nov. 29, 2006. The death toll thus far is fewer than the number of people who die on U.S. roads in a two-day period. The total was 38,253 for the year in 2004, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
2. Gasoline Is a Conspiracy - Going Up or Coming Down
First noticed here (5th item at link), Jack Cafferty at CNN was the primary purveyor of the irresponsible fiction that prices were coming down to make people feel better before the November elections. Because the lie was repeated often enough, it gained some traction with the public, even though there was no supporting evidence of any kind, and even though prices spiked UP a bit in the final week before Election Day.
1. The U.S. economy is hopeless - again.
Garbage — As Larry Kudlow has said time and again, this economy is the “Greatest Story (thanks to our adversary media) Never Told.”
**********
I would add one item to the list, namely that the Bush Administration’s halving of the budget deficit three years ahead of when it was promised went virtually unnoticed. If I had to throw one out, it would be the bird-flu situation, only because I think it’s relatively inconsequential and hasn’t been that successful at falsely scaring people — (UPDATE, Dec. 23: so far).
Regardless, as you can see, not a lot has changed from this post in May of last year, where I identified the origins of business media bias, which is what gave me much of the impetus to start blogging in the first place. If anything, it’s gotten worse.
It will be quite interesting to see how the change in congressional control with the White House in the same hands will affect the reporting on the economy in the coming two years. It would be hard to make the same news good for one party and bad for the other, but I’m sure we’ll see plenty of attempts at just that.









