Iraq and the US: ‘Violent Death’ Stats That Will Iraq Your World
SEE GRAPH AT UPDATE 2.
This post is staying at the top for the rest of Wednesday because of the importance of the topic.
___________________________________
The Associated Press released an interesting set of stats (host link stored for future ref) a couple of days ago that I would suppose were designed to suck away any optimism any fools who still support the mission in Iraq might have (bolds are mine):
BAGHDAD, Iraq - Government officials on Monday reported that 16,273 Iraqi civilians, soldiers and police died violent deaths in 2006, a figure larger than an independent Associated Press count for the year by more than 2,500.
The tabulation by the Iraqi ministries of Health, Defense and Interior, showed that 14,298 civilians, 1,348 police and 627 soldiers were killed in the violence that raged in the country last year.
The Associated Press accounting, gleaned from daily news reports from Baghdad, arrived at a total of 13,738 deaths.
Pretty grim, isn’t it? And this is for “violence that raged in the (whole) country.”
(Aside: Yes, I know I didn’t excerpt the last paragraph about the UN claiming that “100 die each day.” Give me a break — The UN is winging it with no support. And besides, I thought AP, despite Jamil “Captain Tuttle” Hussein, is the gold standard in reporting. Dear reader, you wouldn’t be getting cold feet about AP, would you?)
Man, what a downer. I mean, this is an honest-to-goodness Grade A bona fide quagmire.
So, to reinforce the “obvious” assumption that we simply have to get out now (or at least “redeploy” to, I don’t know, maybe Moose Jaw, Saskatchewan, or something), I decided it would useful to deepen my depression about the fate of the hopelessly lost Iraqi people while making myself feel better about how much safer folks are and have been here in the USA. So I started digging into US murder statistics.
Oops — What I found made me less depressed about Iraq, and more concerned about the US. I even began to wonder why the police in some of our larger cities in the fairly recent past didn’t decide to redeploy to, I don’t know, maybe Mississauga, Ontario, or something. In a couple of the more current cases, I’m half-surprised that the cops haven’t retreated to, I don’t know, Medicine Hat, Alberta, or something.
Anyhow, let’s put this in perspective. Below are 10 listings for US cities and years. Your mission to accomplish (so to speak), is to guess whether each particular city’s murder rate in the year identified was higher or lower than 2006’s “violent death rate” in Iraq (which is, from all appearances, all-inclusive; linked proof to the contrary is welcome –however, Taranto’s Best of the Web from last year that worked with different numbers, a different source, and a different time period doesn’t count). Let’s use the Iraqi government’s higher number of 16,273 just for the heck of it, even though the Associated Press will “surely” be bothered that I’m exaggerating the level of violence compared to what their records show (somehow, I think they’ll get over it). Using the government’s figure means that Iraq’s violent death rate in 2006 was 56.49 per 100,000 residents (16,273 deaths, and a population per Wiki of 28,807,000).
So here are the US cities and the related years:
1. New York City - 1990
2. Washington, DC - 1991
3. Gary, IN - 2005
4. Detroit, MI - 1991
5. Compton, CA - 2005
6. New Orleans, LA - 2006
7. New Orleans, LA - 2004
8. New Orleans, LA - 2003
9. Atlanta, GA - 1973
10. E. St. Louis, IL - 2004
If you’re on the home page, click “more” when you’ve made your guesses (if not, no fair peeking ahead!).
(more…)











