NOTE: I believe this post and the next one (going up tomorrow) have relevance outside of Southwest Ohio. Many local governments are considering illegal immigration laws, and I find it unlikely that metro Cincinnati is the only area where the city’s newspaper and other media outlets are failing to provide, or are misreporting, basic facts about illegal-immigrant cases.
_____________________________________
The City of Mason, northeast of Cincinnati, is looking at doing something about illegal immigration, i.e., Mason is considering doing the job the US Government won’t do (bolded words are part of a pattern of incomplete and inaccurate reporting discussed later; the time-stamp on the article appears to be incorrect, as the meeting reported on took place that evening):
Last Updated: 11:29 am | Monday, January 22, 2007
BY JESSICA BROWN
Mason studies its immigration policy
City Council here agreed Monday to let its safety committee investigate if the city can create local ordinances to crack down on illegal immigration.
….. The moves come about five months after Mason resident Kevin Barnhill, 27, was stabbed to death outside a Mason bar, allegedly at the hands of at least one illegal immigrant. It was the city’s first homicide since 2000. Barnhill’s father, William Barnhill, helped found Citizens for Legal Communities, a Warren County group seeking to strengthen local immigration enforcement.
The group’s primary concern is the increase in violent crime it says illegal immigrants bring to the community - and the lack of enforcement power for local authorities. Monday night, the group asked council to consider creating several immigration ordinances including:
- Making it illegal to harbor, rent or lease residential properties and hotel space for use as an accommodation for an illegal immigrant.
- Requiring employers to use a federal online system to verify that workers are eligible for public benefits.
- Requiring illegal immigrants who are criminally charged to repay court costs incurred for indigent defense or interpreters.
- The group also encouraged council members to petition state legislators for immigration reform. It wants local law enforcement to have authority to prosecute illegal immigrants.
The group will make the same suggestions to other Warren County communities.
Only a handful of towns across the country - and none so far in Ohio - have enacted or are considering local laws to deter immigrants from living or working there. The practice has spurred at least one lawsuit by the American Civil Liberties Union.
Tentative kudos to Mason City Council for looking into passing such laws. Now get the laws written right, and get them on the books. Calling what Council is doing a “crackdown” is way over the top; Council is attempting to create enforceable local laws only because the people in charge of enforcing existing federal laws aren’t doing their jobs.
The fact is that while there is widespread support in Warren County for such measures, it is not very intense. It should be. If our local news outlets were doing their job in reporting crimes committed by illegals in Warren County, it would be.
Here is a perfect example supporting that contention — In a separate story (HT One Oar in the Water) before the meeting just mentioned, Cincinnati Enquirer reporter Jessica Brown previewed it and presented these “facts” to her readers:
(William) Barnhill, of Hamilton Township, formed the (Citizens for Legal Communities) group last year after his son, Kevin Barnhill, was stabbed to death outside of a Mason bar. The suspects, who are awaiting trial, are believed to be illegal immigrants, according to police.
Ms. Brown failed to name the suspects — a borderline call, since the story is about an upcoming meeting and not the murder. But there are two more serious errors:
- Readers of the above paragraph have every reason to believe that ALL of “the” suspects have been apprehended and are awaiting trial. That is NOT the case.
- Readers also would believe that the immigration status of the suspects awaiting trial is uncertain. That is FALSE.
I spoke with Warren County Prosecutor Rachel Hutzel earlier in the week about the Kevin Barnhill murder and the Jose Ocasio Nuñez situation, which will be covered in Part 2 tomorrow. Hutzel informed me of the following concerning the Barnhill case:
- There are three people believed to be involved and who have been indicted for the murder. Two are in custody at the Warren County Jail: Humberto Mota and Jose Mota. The “allegedly at the hands of at least one illegal immigrant” description of the situation in the top story above by Ms. Brown is, very obviously, very misleading.
- One of the three, Enrique Torres, is still at large.
Ms. Brown could have looked at the November 28 Enquirer story on the indictment of all three for murder, which also noted that Torres was on the loose. Oh, and this December 16, 2006 story, also in the Enquirer, indicates that Torres was still at large and that he might still be in the local area. The occasion for the December 16 article was Ms. Hutzel’s public call for help in finding Torres. (Torres is said to have a girlfriend and children in the area, leading Hutzel to believe that he may still be here).
- Part of Ms. Hutzel’s public efforts have involved working with local Channel 12’s Crimestoppers program. Since December 5, there has been a “Special Alert” for Mr. Torres up at the Crimestoppers section of WKRC Channel 12’s web site. Here is his picture in case you see him (there is a reward for info leading to his apprehension):
- As to the immigration status of the three, Ms. Hutzel indicated that Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has “no doubt” that all are illegal immigrants.
- Active attempts to find Torres have been in place throughout multiple law-enforcement jurisdictions, and they remain in place.
- The trial of the two Motas was originally scheduled to begin in February, but has been moved to May because defense lawyers want their cases to be bifurcated into two separate trials, and that issue needs to be resolved first.
Here’s a question for the Cincinnati Enquirer: Why did most of my local-area readers need to learn this information here, and not in their local newspaper of record?
* * * * *
Then there is the case of Jose Ramon Ocasio Nuñez, who was involved in a frightening incident at a Hamilton Township construction site in the summer of 2006, that is covered in Part 2.
_________________________________
UPDATE, Jan. 28: A clean-up point — Jessica Brown wrote that the William Barnhill-led Citizens for Legal Communities “says” that “illegal immigrants bring (an increase in violent crime) to the community,” as if the matter is somehow in dispute.
Follow me closely on this, Ms. Brown:
- The last murder in Mason was in 2000, before the illegal immigrant population in Greater Cincinnati began to be significant. For 5 years, there were no murders. In 2006, there was one, by all accounts allegedly committed by illegal immigrants. So the first murder in six years is “an increase in violent crime,” and it was “brought to the community” (allegedly) by illegal immigrants.
- In the 20-plus years I have lived in Warren County, and the 40-plus years I have lived in Greater Cincinnati, I have never heard of an incident even remotely resembling the Nuñez situation, where a fired employee brought back accomplices with intent to kill someone over being fired. So what Nuñez and his gang accomplices did also represents “an increase in violent crime brought” to Greater Cincinnati by at least one, and probably more, illegal immigrants.
William Barnhill’s group isn’t just “saying” it. It’s a fact — At least two forms of crime in Warren County have increased. Both of those increases can be traced to crimes (allegedly) committed by illegal immigrants. What is unclear about this?