As this was written, the Senate was expected to have its floor vote on cloture today.
Even apart from the economic arguments (just two examples here and here), the national security considerations overwhelmingly argue against passing the monstrosity the Senate is considering. No wonder propoents have to pretend that they have “support” that turns out to be non-existent.
According to The Heritage Foundation’s Kris Kobach, terrorists will have three workable options for carrying on in the US under the Senate’s immigration bill:
Terrorist Option #1: Continue to Operate as an Illegal Alien. The terrorist can simply continue engaging in terrorist planning while remaining unlawfully present in the United States.
This option is particularly easy if the terrorist lives in a sanctuary city, in which the police refuse to inform the federal government when they come into contact with illegal aliens. Most major U.S. cities are now sanctuary cities, including New York City, Los Angeles, and, most recently, Detroit. Detroit’s huge population of Middle Eastern immigrants provides perfect cover for newly arrived terrorists from the Middle East.
Terrorists know all about sanctuary cities and the concealment that such cities provide. The Fort Dix terrorists are a case in point…..
Terrorist Option #2: Obtain the Amnesty Using One’s Real Name. Seeking amnesty under one’s real name is a promising option for any terrorist who has operated completely underground during his terrorist career. This is also a likely choice for a terrorist who has been recruited into Islamic jihad only recently. Such an individual will not have a record of past terrorist activity maintained by any government.
Unfortunately, it is also a realistic option for a terrorist who is actually known by foreign governments to be involved in a terrorist organization. Under the Senate immigration bill, there is virtually no chance that the federal government will discover his terrorist connections in time…..
Terrorist Option #3: Invent a Clean Identity With the Help of the U.S. Government. The third option is perhaps the most troubling. The Senate bill fails to provide any safeguards against terrorists who invent entirely “clean” identities. Because the bill contains no requirement that the alien produce a secure foreign passport proving his identity, terrorists will have little trouble gaming the system.
A terrorist can walk into a USCIS office and offer a completely fictitious name–one that does not have any negative information associated with it. In other words, a terrorist can declare that his name is “Rumpelstiltskin,” or perhaps “Mohammed X,” and most likely, walk out the next day with a probationary Z visa, complete with a government-issued ID card backing up his false identity.
The terrorist need only provide two easily forged pieces of paper indicating that a person of that name was in the country before January 1, 2007. A pay stub, a bank receipt, or a remittance receipt would suffice, as does a declaration from one of the terrorist’s friends that he was in the country before January 1, 2007.
With this newly minted identity backed up by an ID card issued by the federal government, the alien terrorist will be armed with the perfect “breeder document,” allowing him to obtain driver’s licenses and just about any other form of identification that he desires. This is essentially what the 19 9/11 hijackers did: They used their passports and visas as breeder documents to obtain 63 driver’s licenses.
Totally, unacceptable. A vote for cloture is a vote for enshrining defenselessness and guaranteeing economic mediocrity, or worse. No, way.